The Best Superhero Titles? (Story, World Building, Chars., etc.)
There's A LOT of Superhero adjacent titles out there, so these are just some that I personally know of (recensy bias of course)
Champion

To Be Hero X
To Be Hero X
Winner
Moon Knight (MARVEL)
Eliminated
Infamous
Winner
HELLBOY
Eliminated
Invincible
Winner
Hancock
Eliminated
Ben 10
Winner
Control
Eliminated
Avengers (MARVEL)
Winner
Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man (MARVEL)
Eliminated
The Spider Verse (MARVEL)
Winner
Fantastic Four (MARVEL)
Eliminated
The Batman (DC)
Winner
Viewtiful Joe
Eliminated
Teen Titans (DC)
Winner
Powerpuff Girls
Eliminated
Dispatch
Winner
Danny Phantom
Eliminated
V for Vendetta
Winner
What If...? (MARVEL)
Eliminated
Guardians of The Galaxy (MARVEL)
Winner
Heroman
Eliminated
Thunderbolts* (MARVEL)
Winner
Static Shock (DC)
Eliminated
Justice League (DC)
Winner
Dredd
Eliminated
My Hero Academia
Winner
Shy
Eliminated
Spectacular Spider-Man (MARVEL)
Winner
Gravity Rush
Eliminated
Deadpool (MARVEL)
Winner
Blade (MARVEL)
Eliminated
Avengers Earths Mightiest Heroes
Winner
Morbius (MARVEL)
Eliminated
Superman (DC)
Winner
Young Justice (DC)
Eliminated
My Adventures With Superman (DC)
Winner
Tiger & Bunny
Eliminated
ZETMAN
Winner
Gatchaman Crowds
Eliminated
Peacemaker (DC)
Winner
Marvel Zombies (MARVEL)
Eliminated
SPAWN
Winner
Watchmen
Eliminated
Loki (MARVEL)
Winner
Darkwing Duck
Eliminated
Venom (MARVEL)
Winner
Gen V
Eliminated
Creature Commandos (DC)
Winner
Ghost Rider (MARVEL)
Eliminated
The Suicide Squad (MARVEL)
Winner
Injustice
Eliminated
X-MEN '97 (MARVEL)
Winner
Super Crooks
Eliminated
One Punch Man
Winner
South Park The Fractured But Whole
Eliminated
Daredevil (MARVEL)
Winner
Kick-Ass
Eliminated
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Winner
Harley Quinn (DC)
Eliminated
Kraven The Hunter (MARVEL)
Winner
Ganglion
Eliminated
Sky High
Winner
Madame Web (MARVEL)
Eliminated