Poppy Playtime
Winner
Picky Piggy Plush
Eliminated
Cartoon Poe
Winner
CatNap (Minecraft)
Eliminated
Cartoon Hobby Hopscotch
Winner
DogDay Plush
Eliminated
CatNap
Winner
Mommy Long Legs
Eliminated
Bubba Bubbaphant Plush
Winner
Monster Doey The Doughman (Minecraft)
Eliminated
The Doctor Harley Sawyer (Yellow Eye)
Winner
Red Huggie Buddie
Eliminated
Kickin Chicken Plush
Winner
Boogie Bot (damaged)
Eliminated
Nightmare Huggy Wuggy
Winner
Pianosaurus
Eliminated
Icky Licky
Winner
Cartoon Maggie Macko
Eliminated
Bunzo Bunny (monster)
Winner
Bobby Bearhug Plush
Eliminated
Doey The Doughman
Winner
Purple Huggie Buddie
Eliminated
DogDay
Winner
Evil CatNap Plush
Eliminated
Green Huggie Buddie
Winner
Cartoon Simon Smokes
Eliminated
Catbee
Winner
Cartoon Mommy Long Legs
Eliminated
The Doctor Harley Sawyer (red eye)
Winner
Baba Chops
Eliminated
Kissy Missy
Winner
Candy Cat
Eliminated
Cartoon DogDay
Winner
Cartoon Bron
Eliminated
CatNap Plush
Winner
Miss Delight
Eliminated
Boxy Boo
Winner
Bron
Eliminated
Evil Kickin Chicken Plush
Winner
Cartoon Catbee
Eliminated
Cartoon Bunzo Bunny
Winner
Orange Huggie Buddie
Eliminated
Cartoon Bubba Bubbaphant
Winner
Cartoon Baba Chops
Eliminated
Cartoon Icky Licky
Winner
Huggy Wuggy (Minecraft)
Eliminated
Cartoon Pianosaurus
Winner
Poe
Eliminated
Huggy Wuggy
Winner
Cartoon Kickin Chicken
Eliminated
Bron (damaged)
Winner
Doey The Doughman (Minecraft)
Eliminated
Huggy Wuggy (smiling) (Minecraft)
Winner
Player Avatar
Eliminated
Evil DogDay Plush
Winner
Maggie Macko
Eliminated
Huggy Wuggy (smiling)
Winner
Cartoon CatNap
Eliminated
Mommy Long Legs (Minecraft)
Winner
Simon Smoke
Eliminated
Boogie Bot
Winner
Evil Hopscotch
Eliminated
Doey The Doughman (Angry)
Winner
Touille
Eliminated
Cartoon Alister Gator
Winner
Alister Gator
Eliminated
The Doctor Harley Sawyer
Winner
Evil Bobby Bearhug Plush
Eliminated
Blue Huggie Buddie
Winner
Evil Bubba Bubbaphant Plush
Eliminated
Yarnaby
Winner
Cartoon Bobby Bearhug
Eliminated