Nandi Bear
Winner
Skinwalker
Eliminated
Hydra
Winner
Mermaid
Eliminated
Not Deer
Winner
Moa
Eliminated
Dover Demon
Winner
Tasmanian Tiger
Eliminated
Fresno Nightcrawler
Winner
Fairy
Eliminated
Megalodon
Winner
Chupacabra
Eliminated
Kraken
Winner
King Otter
Eliminated
Mothman
Winner
Mongolian Death Worm
Eliminated
Loch Ness Monster
Winner
Jersey Devil
Eliminated
Loveland Frog
Winner
Siren
Eliminated
Sea Serpent
Winner
Phoenix
Eliminated
Mapinguari
Winner
Gnome
Eliminated
Champy
Winner
Unicorn
Eliminated
Sirenhead
Winner
Dragon
Eliminated
Bigfoot
Winner
Yeti
Eliminated