Lilah
Winner
TheFirst
Eliminated
Inca Princess
Winner
Billy
Eliminated
Husband
Winner
Willy
Eliminated
Professor Walsh
Winner
Parker
Eliminated
Tara
Winner
CheeseMan
Eliminated
Linwood
Winner
Justine
Eliminated
Faith
Winner
Doc
Eliminated
Graham
Winner
Anointed
Eliminated
VirginiaBryce
Winner
Holland Manners
Eliminated
Oz
Winner
Harmonyyyy
Eliminated
Spike
Winner
Jesse
Eliminated
Riley
Winner
Holtz
Eliminated
Dawn
Winner
Forrest
Eliminated
Andrew
Winner
Hank
Eliminated
Groosalugg
Winner
Ford
Eliminated
Lindsay
Winner
Buffybot
Eliminated
Fred
Winner
Sahjhan
Eliminated
Cassie
Winner
GayKathy
Eliminated
Sunday
Winner
HearMeOut
Eliminated
Dennis
Winner
Warren
Eliminated
Fredsparents
Winner
BachelorParty
Eliminated
Anne
Winner
Rack
Eliminated
Mayorrrrr
Winner
Veruca
Eliminated
VampWillow
Winner
Gwendolyn Post
Eliminated
Doyle
Winner
Oracles
Eliminated
April
Winner
Gavin
Eliminated
Sweet
Winner
Joyce
Eliminated
Drusilla
Winner
Darla
Eliminated
William
Winner
Dracula
Eliminated
Buffy
Winner
Flutie
Eliminated
Wesley
Winner
Merl
Eliminated
Gunn
Winner
Sam
Eliminated
Ethan
Winner
Holden
Eliminated
Connor
Winner
LoanShark
Eliminated
BabyConnor
Winner
Skip
Eliminated
Glory
Winner
Angel
Eliminated
Dhoffryn
Winner
Master
Eliminated
Snyder
Winner
Katrina
Eliminated
Jenny
Winner
Sineya
Eliminated